• Home
    • About OnlineRaceDriver
  • Racing Game Car Lists
  • History of Racing Games
  • Wheels & Pedals
  • Esports
  • Trackipedia Race Sim Track Lists

OnlineRaceDriver

Sim Racing News, Tips and Guides

  • Forza
    • Forza Motorsport 7
    • Forza Motorsport
    • Forza Horizon 4
  • gran turismo
    • Gran Turismo Sport
    • Gran Turismo 7
  • iracing
  • rFactor
    • rFactor 2
  • GRID
  • RaceRoom
  • Assetto Corsa
    • Assetto Corsa Competizione
  • DiRT
    • DiRT 5
    • DiRT Rally 2.0
  • Wreckfest
  • Automobilista
    • Automobilista 2
  • ATS
  • ETS 2
  • F1 2020
    • F1 2019
  • KartKraft
  • Project CARS 3
    • Project CARS 2
  • Test Drive Unlimited
    • Test Drive Unlimited Solar Crown
  • More Driving Games
    • Overpass
    • MotoGP 20
    • SnowRunner
    • RIDE 4
    • Spintires

Time for the commentary to cease

August 9, 2010 By TomBowker Leave a Comment

Often confusing, irritating and hilarious in equal measures, commentary in racing games has for too long been appalling. The PlayStation’s F1 ‘97 was legendary for all the wrong reasons. Murray Walker is, in my opinion, the greatest commentator of all time in any sport, but the game made him out to be some kind of maniac hell-bent on listing who the top-ten drivers were at least twice per-lap and only reacting to major incidents at least half a minute after they had occurred. And whilst that game was released thirteen years ago, things have not improved much.

Time for the commentary to cease

Time for the commentary to cease

Commentary Box image on Flickr by sbisson. (CC Licence)

I argue that such poor commentary systems detract from the overall experience of the game and serve to undermine the user’s enjoyment of playing it. I have never understood why commentary in racing games use such few phrases – it seems like developers get the voice talent into the recording studio and then say ‘well, we’ll need you to record a bit for the start… um, say the driver’s names… do a couple of exclamations for crashes and stuff… and then we’ll just loop them a few times and we can all go home early and pat ourselves on the back’. The result of this lack of variety is that repetitive, benign, irritating and distracting voices have left gamers frustrated for far too long. I believe is also a very valid argument for actually killing developers who have released an ‘update game’ twelve months on from the first and haven’t even bothered to update the commentary, let alone improve it. ‘Well, we all said it was brilliant last year, so let’s just use it again’. There is simply no excuse.

Racing games are obviously not the only culprit when it comes to appalling commentary. The Pro Evolution Soccer series for example has had terrible commentary for such a long time that it’s fans have come to regard it as more charming than irritating, hence this amusing tribute which is not too far off the real thing. Some blame the commentators themselves, some the programming code, and others the like-for-like Japanese translations which have made many a Nintendo game all the more amusing over the years. But in this day and age and as technology advances, I say the time has come for this practice to cease.

Not all racing games are culprits – for example the Gran Turismo series has never had a commentator, but does instead insist on giving you background music as the default setting. Kazunori Yamauchi and Polyphony Digital may be the kings of the simulation, but I personally have never seen a racing car with a working radio inside it. Thankfully you can turn this off in the options menu and avoid the noise of generic rock music drowning out the beautifully-recreated sound of your roaring engine.

The key debate regarding in-game commentary lies in whether a sports game chooses to simulate the sport or the TV presentation of it. Games have for too long been stuck in limbo – a hybrid area between the two that doesn’t make sense to the gamer. There is no reason in a racing game for the player to be able to hear a television commentator during the race, let alone a television commentator AND an engineer broadcasting pit-to-car radio transmissions – such as in F1 2006 on the PS2. In Codemasters’ Colin McRae: Dirt, your co-driver Travis Pastrana is not only the in-game voiceover but also races against you, which makes it pretty difficult to suspend your disbelief. Are we to presume Travis is reading our pace notes whilst driving his own car? Or are there two of Travis Pastrana? Thankfully Dirt:2 provides the option to choose a different voice, although all of the potential selections sound nothing like they have ever been anywhere near a fast-moving vehicle, and suspiciously more like they have spent the morning sat in a recording booth helping themselves to too many free croissants.

To solve this gaming commentary crisis, I suggest this: the answer for developers is to make a choice about what they are choosing to represent – it has to be either the driving simulation or the broadcast simulation and make no attempt to create the ‘best of both worlds’. Studios must choose one option and stick to it, because a half-way house is never satisfying for the user, always confusing, and I would argue is yet to work effectively in any racing game to date.

Codemasters appear to be on the ball with this idea and have decided against having any in-game commentary for their fantastic-looking forthcoming F1 2010. Until such times as in-game commentary can be advanced enough that we hear intelligent comments from Jonathan Legard and Martin Brundle that relate directly to the action, and we can see and hear authentic, competent and articulate virtual versions of Jake Humphrey, David Coulthard and Eddie Jordan making specific post-race assessments of my driving then surely, for now at least, less has to be more. I would love for this approach to work properly but I think a satisfying simulation is a fair few years off yet. So for now, I say scrap the TV-route altogether and stick to simulating the driving experience. OK?!

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Pocket (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Blog, FeaturedContent, Formula One, gran turismo, Playstation 2, Playstation 3, Rallying Tagged With: background music, colin mcrae, commentary, engine noise, in-game audio, james allen, murray walker, online racing, racing games, travis pastrana

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Social

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Categories

Latest Videos

The Nissan Proto Z and Racing Conversion in Project CARS 3 Power Pack DLC

Project CARS 3 Power Pack DLC and Update 4 Out Now

There's a new circuit, various game improvements, and four new paid cars to … Watch now

A new iRacing 2021 Season 2 Video Preview demonstrates the new damage model coming to more cars

iRacing 2021 Season 2 Video: New Damage Model For More Cars

An iRacing 2021 Season 2 video preview has revealed more cars will move onto the … Watch now

Forza Horizon 4 Hot Wheels Legends DLC Released

Forza Horizon 4 Hot Wheels Legends DLC Released

Leaked at the start of February and mentioned in the monthly Forza stream and … Watch now

MotoGP 21 Announced for Release on April 22nd 2021

MotoGP 21 Announced for Release on April 22nd 2021

The simulation of the top level of motorcycle racing will be available on next … Watch now

New Wreckfest Reckless Car Pack And Free Update

New Wreckfest Reckless Car Pack And Free Update

More crashing and smashing from developers Bugbear Entertainment, with a new … Watch now

Forza Horizon 4 is coming to Steam on March 9,2021

Forza Horizon 4 Is Coming To Steam On March 9

In a move to boost the PC popularity of the game, Forza Horizon 4 is coming to … Watch now

More Videos

Popular Posts

  • The rFactor 2 Car List
    The rFactor 2 Car List
  • How to perform stunts in MX vs ATV Alive
    How to perform stunts in MX vs ATV Alive
  • The rFactor 2 Track List
    The rFactor 2 Track List
  • How To Install Mods For Assetto Corsa
    How To Install Mods For Assetto Corsa
  • Complete Official Wreckfest Car List
    Complete Official Wreckfest Car List
  • The Automobilista 2 Track List
    The Automobilista 2 Track List
  • The Full Assetto Corsa Competizione Track List
    The Full Assetto Corsa Competizione Track List
  • Cool Home-Made Porsche 911 GTE Sim Racing Wheel
    Cool Home-Made Porsche 911 GTE Sim Racing Wheel
  • The Full Automobilista 2 Car List
    The Full Automobilista 2 Car List
  • New iRacing GT3 Challenge Fixed Series Announced
    New iRacing GT3 Challenge Fixed Series Announced

Subscribe to the weekly ORD Newsletter and never miss Sim Racing news

* indicates required

View previous campaigns.

Powered by MailChimp

Useful Links

Sim Racing Game Car Lists
Sim Racing Game Track Lists
The Best Sim Racing Wheels For Beginners

Categories

Connect with us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

© 2021 Hot Mod Media · Design & Marketing TWOTW · Disposable Media · FPSPrestige · OnlineRaceDriver · Patchwork Kitchen · HotModGaming · The Guitar List · Rescars · Rescogs

Go to mobile version